Committee warns banks: we are watching you

24 July 2009

In a report published today, the Business and Enterprise Committee says the Enterprise Finance Guarantee Scheme (EFG) appears to be working well but expresses concern about potential behaviour of some banks involved in the scheme

The Committee notes that when lending dried up after the credit crunch there were criticisms of lack of speedy government help for business. The Enterprise Finance Guarantee Scheme was introduced on 14 January to help the flow of credit to small and medium size enterprises.

Baroness Vadera described the scheme as "to help those at the margins"; some problems arose because expectations were raised too highly, in part because of inaccurate reporting. However, when the Committee took evidence on 2 June, the witnesses agreed the scheme was working well. The Committee concludes:

It is important we recognise when the Government does get it right. Although it is limited in scope and cannot help all struggling businesses, the Enterprise Finance Guarantee scheme now appears to be working well, after a relatively slow start.

However, the Committee expresses concern about the potential behaviour of some of the banks involved in the scheme and today invites evidence from businesses to monitor this.

The Government left the decision as to which companies should benefit from its financial guarantees to the banks. In the Committee’s view this places a great responsibility on the banks to ensure that those eligible for the scheme benefit from it. While it is understandable that, in some cases, banks have had to refuse companies access to the scheme because they have doubts about the long-term viability of the business, Committee members have also been made aware of cases where banks are not offering companies a choice, instead offering single measures, such as factoring, to businesses which would be eligible to benefit from this scheme.

Therefore, to coincide with the publication of today’s Report, the Committee are inviting businesses to submit evidence if they feel they have had experience of this happening.

Peter Luff, Committee Chairman, said:

"While we are largely impressed by the way the EFG scheme has been handled, it depends on banks offering appropriate help to their customers. We will be monitoring whether the scheme is being offered appropriate, and will return to this issue in the autumn if necessary, after having heard directly from businesses. We encourage as many businesses to submit evidence to us as possible."

While the Committee is interested in hearing companies’ experiences, it will not be able to intervene in individual cases, or make judgments as to whether companies are financially viable. These should be sent, as an MS Word document, of no more than eight pages, by e-mail to with a single hard copy sent to the Clerk of the Committee at Business and Enterprise Committee Committee, Committee Office, House of Commons, London, SW1A 0AA.

Once submitted evidence is the property of the Committee and should not be published without the Committee’s consent. The Committee will usually publish evidence it receives, both in printed form and on the Internet. If you wish your evidence to remain confidential, please contact the Committee staff. Before submitting evidence, please read the guide to submission of written evidence.

Image: iStockphoto

More news on: Parliament, government and politics, Parliament, Economy and finance, Business, industry and consumers, Business support, Economic situation, Financial institutions, Financial services, Commons news, Parliamentary business, Committee news

Share this page