Former top Scottish Judge questioned on Scottish independence impact

12 February 2014

The House of Lords Constitution Committee will tomorrow hold its first evidence session in its inquiry into the constitutional implications for the rest of the UK of Scottish independence. The Committee will open the inquiry by taking evidence from Lord Hope of Craighead and Professor Iain McLean. 


Lord Hope of Craighead was Lord President of the Court of Session and Lord Justice General—Scotland’s highest judge—before becoming a Law Lord then the first Deputy President of the UK Supreme Court between 2009–2013.

Professor McLean is Professor of Politics at Nuffield College, University of Oxford, and is an expert on devolution and constitutional reform.

Session details

At 10.30am, Wednesday 12 February 2014, Committee room 1, Palace of Westminster:

  • Rt Hon. Lord Hope of Craighead, KT, former deputy president of the Supreme Court
  • Professor Iain McLean, Professor of Politics at Nuffield College, University of Oxford

Likely questions

Areas the Committee are likely to cover with the witnesses include:

  • What legal principles should govern negotiations for Scottish independence in the event of a “yes” vote?
  • Is the timetable of independence by March 2016 realistic? What impact will the timing of the UK general election in May 2015 have on this timetable?
  • What legal measures would be needed to allow negotiations to take place?
  • Who would negotiate for the remainder of the UK and to whom should they be accountable?
  • What would happen if the two negotiating teams could not agree on an issue?
  • What would be the status of the 59 MPs for Scottish constituencies in 2015–16?
  • What impact would Scottish independence have on the work and membership of the UK Supreme Court?

Further information

Image: Press Association  

More news on: Parliament, government and politics, Parliament, House of Lords news, Lords news, Scotland, Committee news, Constitution

Share this page