Early day motion 2649

Main content

Follow this EDM by:

MYELOMA TREATMENT AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH AND CLINICAL EXCELLENCE RULING ON VELCADE

That this House notes with concern that the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence's (NICE) Single Technology Appraisal Consultation Document on Velcade does not recommend this treatment for use in the NHS except as part of ongoing or new clinical trials; further notes that this is the only new treatment licensed for use in myeloma patients in the past 10 years and represents a major step forward in the treatment of this cancer, which has one of the highest death rates of all cancers; recognises that this treatment has been positively appraised by the Scottish Medicines Consortium and the All Wales Medicines Strategy Group, currently making it available to patients in Scotland and Wales, and that within its licence it has been endorsed for use by the UK Myeloma Forum and the British Committee for Standards in Haematology; further notes that the clinical and cost-effectiveness analysis of this treatment demonstrates that the cost per life year gained was between £28,000 and £31,000 for treatment at first relapse, which is within the NICE requirements for cost effectiveness; and therefore requests that the Secretary of State for Health asks NICE to reconsider the evidence before issuing its final appraisal determination.

Filter EDMs by:

Total number of signatures: 68

  1. Show:

    Click for glossary

    Glossary

    Supported by:
    A list of all MPs that have signed and support the motion.
    Withdrawn:
    A list of MPs that have withdrawn their signature from the motion.

Showing 68 out of 68

Name Party Constituency Date Signed
Anderson, Janet Labour Party Rossendale and Darwen 10.10.2006
Austin, Ian Labour Party Dudley North 09.10.2006
Brake, Tom Liberal Democrats Carshalton and Wallington 24.10.2006
Burrowes, David Conservative Party Enfield Southgate 30.10.2006
Campbell, Gregory Democratic Unionist Party Londonderry East 11.10.2006
Carswell, Douglas Conservative Party Harwich 09.10.2006
Caton, Martin Labour Party Gower 11.10.2006
Chaytor, David Labour Party Bury North 09.10.2006
Clapham, Michael Labour Party Barnsley West and Penistone 24.10.2006
Cohen, Harry Labour Party Leyton and Wanstead 18.10.2006
Conway, Derek Conservative Party Old Bexley and Sidcup 11.10.2006
Cook, Frank Labour Party Stockton North 30.10.2006
Corbyn, Jeremy Labour Party Islington North 11.10.2006
Cryer, Ann Labour Party Keighley 10.10.2006
David, Wayne Labour Party Caerphilly 16.10.2006
Davies, Dai INDEPENDENT Blaenau Gwent 23.10.2006
Davies, Quentin Conservative Party Grantham and Stamford 30.10.2006
Dean, Janet Labour Party Burton 12.10.2006
Dobbin, Jim Labour Party Heywood and Middleton 09.10.2006
Dodds, Nigel Democratic Unionist Party Belfast North 18.10.2006
Donaldson, Jeffrey Democratic Unionist Party Lagan Valley 10.10.2006
Durkan, Mark Social Democratic and Labour Party Foyle 11.10.2006
Ennis, Jeff Labour Party Barnsley East and Mexborough 12.10.2006
Etherington, Bill Labour Party Sunderland North 24.10.2006
Farron, Tim Liberal Democrats Westmorland and Lonsdale 18.10.2006
Featherstone, Lynne Liberal Democrats Hornsey and Wood Green 16.10.2006
Francis, Hywel Labour Party Aberavon 11.10.2006
George, Andrew Liberal Democrats St Ives 10.10.2006
Gibson, Ian Labour Party Norwich North 10.10.2006
Goodwill, Robert Conservative Party Scarborough and Whitby 25.10.2006
Griffith, Nia Labour Party Llanelli 20.10.2006
Hancock, Mike Liberal Democrats Portsmouth South 11.10.2006
Hands, Greg Conservative Party Hammersmith and Fulham 19.10.2006
Havard, Dai Labour Party Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney 26.10.2006
Hemming, John Liberal Democrats Birmingham Yardley 09.10.2006
Hepburn, Stephen Labour Party Jarrow 23.10.2006
Hodgson, Sharon Labour Party Gateshead East and Washington West 24.10.2006
Hopkins, Kelvin Labour Party Luton North 11.10.2006
Hoyle, Lindsay Labour Party Chorley 10.10.2006
Hunter, Mark Liberal Democrats Cheadle 25.10.2006
Iddon, Brian Labour Party Bolton South East 17.10.2006
Jenkins, Brian Labour Party Tamworth 19.10.2006
Jones, Martyn Labour Party Clwyd South 18.10.2006
Keetch, Paul Liberal Democrats Hereford 09.10.2006
Lloyd, Tony Labour Party Manchester Central 24.10.2006
Malik, Shahid Labour Party Dewsbury 26.10.2006
Marsden, Gordon Labour Party Blackpool South 10.10.2006
McCarthy, Kerry Labour Party Bristol East 20.10.2006
McCrea, Dr William Democratic Unionist Party South Antrim 10.10.2006
McDonnell, John Labour Party Hayes and Harlington 12.10.2006
Miller, Andrew Labour Party Ellesmere Port and Neston 19.10.2006
Morden, Jessica Labour Party Newport East 25.07.2006
Neill, Robert Conservative Party Bromley and Chislehurst 07.11.2006
Owen, Albert Labour Party Ynys Môn 10.10.2006
Pelling, Andrew Conservative Party Croydon Central 01.11.2006
Penning, Mike Conservative Party Hemel Hempstead 25.07.2006
Robinson, Iris Democratic Unionist Party Strangford 09.10.2006
Simpson, David Democratic Unionist Party Upper Bann 10.10.2006
Singh, Marsha Labour Party Bradford West 12.10.2006
Spink, Bob Conservative Party Castle Point 16.10.2006
Stewart, Ian Labour Party Eccles 26.10.2006
Taylor, David Labour Party North West Leicestershire 19.10.2006
Turner, Desmond Labour Party Brighton Kemptown 24.10.2006
Vis, Rudi Labour Party Finchley and Golders Green 11.10.2006
Williams, Betty Labour Party Conwy 16.10.2006
Williams, Mark Liberal Democrats Ceredigion 19.10.2006
Willis, Phil Liberal Democrats Harrogate and Knaresborough 30.10.2006
Wilson, Sammy Democratic Unionist Party East Antrim 16.10.2006