Lords Divisions results

View the results of votes in the House of Lords. Results, displayed by affiliation (party or group), should be available soon after the vote.

Find the results of a division Find the results of a division
Date Title

31 October 2017 - Division 1

Financial Guidance and Claims Bill [HL]

Lord Sharkey moved amendment 24, in clause 3, page 3, line 15, at end to insert:

“( ) In Schedule 3 to the Pensions Schemes Act 2015 (pensions guidance), after paragraph 6(3) insert:

“(3A) In determining what provision to include in the rules, the FCA must include a requirement for the trustees or managers of a relevant pension scheme to ask members of the scheme or survivors of members of the scheme at the point at which they require access to or individual transfer of their pension assets, if they have received the information and guidance available under section 3 of the Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2017 (specific requirements as to the pensions guidance function); and if they have not received such information and guidance the FCA may require the relevant trustee or manager to provide access to such information and guidance before proceeding.””

The House divided:

Contents: 283 | Not Contents: 201 | Result: Government Defeat
Contents Total: 283
Bishops 2
Oxford, Bishop Content  
St Albans, Bishop Content  
Conservative 4
Altmann, Baroness Content  
Deben, Lord Content  
Lupton, Lord Content  
Wheatcroft, Baroness Content  
Crossbench 53
Aberdare, Lord Content  
Alton of Liverpool, Lord Content  
Best, Lord Content  
Bichard, Lord Content  
Birt, Lord Content  
Boyce, Lord Content  
Brookeborough, Viscount Content  
Brown of Cambridge, Baroness Content  
Clancarty, Earl Content  
Coussins, Baroness Content  
Craig of Radley, Lord Content  
Craigavon, Viscount Content  
Crisp, Lord Content  
Curry of Kirkharle, Lord Content  
D'Souza, Baroness Content  
Eames, Lord Content  
Elystan-Morgan, Lord Content  
Erroll, Earl Content  
Falkland, Viscount Content  
Finlay of Llandaff, Baroness Content  
Ford, Baroness Content  
Freyberg, Lord Content  
Hayman, Baroness Content  
Hollins, Baroness Content  
Hope of Craighead, Lord Content  
Howe of Idlicote, Baroness Content  
Kerr of Kinlochard, Lord Content  
Kidron, Baroness Content  
Kinnoull, Earl Content  
Laming, Lord Content  
Low of Dalston, Lord Content  
Lytton, Earl Content  
Mair, Lord Content  
Mar, Countess Content  
Masham of Ilton, Baroness Content  
Meacher, Baroness Content  
Morgan of Drefelin, Baroness Content  
O'Neill of Bengarve, Baroness Content  
Oxburgh, Lord Content  
Patel, Lord Content  
Rowe-Beddoe, Lord Content  
Sandwich, Earl Content  
Singh of Wimbledon, Lord Content  
Skidelsky, Lord Content  
Stern, Baroness Content  
Thurlow, Lord Content  
Trees, Lord Content  
Turnbull, Lord Content  
Vaux of Harrowden, Lord Content  
Warner, Lord Content  
Watkins of Tavistock, Baroness Content  
Wilson of Tillyorn, Lord Content  
Young of Hornsey, Baroness Content  
Labour 138
Adams of Craigielea, Baroness Content  
Adonis, Lord Content  
Anderson of Swansea, Lord Content  
Andrews, Baroness Content  
Armstrong of Hill Top, Baroness Content  
Bakewell, Baroness Content  
Bassam of Brighton, Lord Content  
Beecham, Lord Content  
Berkeley, Lord Content  
Blackstone, Baroness Content  
Blood, Baroness Content  
Blunkett, Lord Content  
Bradley, Lord Content  
Bragg, Lord Content  
Brennan, Lord Content  
Brookman, Lord Content  
Browne of Ladyton, Lord Content  
Campbell-Savours, Lord Content  
Carter of Coles, Lord Content  
Cashman, Lord Content  
Chakrabarti, Baroness Content  
Christopher, Lord Content  
Clark of Windermere, Lord Content  
Clarke of Hampstead, Lord Content  
Collins of Highbury, Lord Content  
Corston, Baroness Content  
Crawley, Baroness Content  
Cunningham of Felling, Lord Content  
Darling of Roulanish, Lord Content  
Davidson of Glen Clova, Lord Content  
Davies of Oldham, Lord Content  
Desai, Lord Content  
Donaghy, Baroness Content  
Donoughue, Lord Content  
Drake, Baroness Content  
Dubs, Lord Content  
Elder, Lord Content  
Evans of Watford, Lord Content  
Farrington of Ribbleton, Baroness Content  
Faulkner of Worcester, Lord Content  
Foulkes of Cumnock, Lord Content  
Gale, Baroness Content  
Giddens, Lord Content  
Golding, Baroness Content  
Gordon of Strathblane, Lord Content  
Goudie, Baroness Content  
Gould of Potternewton, Baroness Content  
Grantchester, Lord Content  
Grocott, Lord Content  
Hain, Lord Content  
Hanworth, Viscount Content  
Harris of Haringey, Lord Content  
Haskel, Lord Content  
Haworth, Lord Content  
Hayter of Kentish Town, Baroness Content  
Healy of Primrose Hill, Baroness Content  
Henig, Baroness Content  
Hollick, Lord Content  
Hollis of Heigham, Baroness Content  
Howarth of Newport, Lord Content  
Howells of St Davids, Baroness Content  
Howie of Troon, Lord Content  
Hoyle, Lord Content  
Hughes of Woodside, Lord Content  
Jay of Paddington, Baroness Content  
Jones of Whitchurch, Baroness Content  
Jones, Lord Content  
Judd, Lord Content  
Kennedy of Cradley, Baroness Content  
Kennedy of Southwark, Lord Content  
Kennedy of The Shaws, Baroness Content  
Kinnock of Holyhead, Baroness Content  
Kinnock, Lord Content  
Kirkhill, Lord Content  
Lawrence of Clarendon, Baroness Content  
Layard, Lord Content  
Lea of Crondall, Lord Content  
Lennie, Lord Content  
Liddell of Coatdyke, Baroness Content  
Liddle, Lord Content  
Lipsey, Lord Content  
Livermore, Lord Content  
Mallalieu, Baroness Content  
Massey of Darwen, Baroness Content  
Maxton, Lord Content  
McAvoy, Lord Content  
McConnell of Glenscorrodale, Lord Content  
McDonagh, Baroness Content  
McIntosh of Hudnall, Baroness Content  
McKenzie of Luton, Lord Content  
Mendelsohn, Lord Content  
Monks, Lord Content  
Morris of Aberavon, Lord Content  
Morris of Handsworth, Lord Content  
Murphy of Torfaen, Lord Content  
Nye, Baroness Content  
O'Neill of Clackmannan, Lord Content  
Patel of Bradford, Lord Content  
Pendry, Lord Content  
Ponsonby of Shulbrede, Lord Content  
Prescott, Lord Content  
Primarolo, Baroness Content  
Puttnam, Lord Content  
Quin, Baroness Content  
Radice, Lord Content  
Ramsay of Cartvale, Baroness Content  
Rebuck, Baroness Content  
Richard, Lord Content  
Robertson of Port Ellen, Lord Content  
Rooker, Lord Content  
Rosser, Lord Content  
Rowlands, Lord Content  
Sawyer, Lord Content  
Sherlock, Baroness Content  
Simon, Viscount Content  
Smith of Basildon, Baroness Content  
Smith of Gilmorehill, Baroness Content  
Smith of Leigh, Lord Content  
Snape, Lord Content  
Soley, Lord Content  
Stevenson of Balmacara, Lord Content  
Taylor of Bolton, Baroness Content  
Temple-Morris, Lord Content  
Thornton, Baroness Content  
Tomlinson, Lord Content  
Touhig, Lord Content  
Tunnicliffe, Lord Content  
Warwick of Undercliffe, Baroness Content  
Watson of Invergowrie, Lord Content  
Watts, Lord Content  
West of Spithead, Lord Content  
Wheeler, Baroness Content  
Whitaker, Baroness Content  
Whitty, Lord Content  
Winston, Lord Content  
Wood of Anfield, Lord Content  
Woolmer of Leeds, Lord Content  
Young of Old Scone, Baroness Content  
Liberal Democrat 75
Addington, Lord Content  
Allan of Hallam, Lord Content  
Barker, Baroness Content  
Beith, Lord Content  
Benjamin, Baroness Content  
Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury, Baroness Content  
Bowles of Berkhamsted, Baroness Content  
Bradshaw, Lord Content  
Brinton, Baroness Content  
Bruce of Bennachie, Lord Content  
Burt of Solihull, Baroness Content  
Campbell of Pittenweem, Lord Content  
Chidgey, Lord Content  
Clement-Jones, Lord Content  
Cotter, Lord Content  
Dholakia, Lord Content  
Doocey, Baroness Content  
Falkner of Margravine, Baroness Content  
Fearn, Lord Content  
Featherstone, Baroness Content  
Fox, Lord Content  
Garden of Frognal, Baroness Content  
German, Lord Content  
Glasgow, Earl Content  
Goddard of Stockport, Lord Content  
Greaves, Lord Content  
Grender, Baroness Content  
Hamwee, Baroness Content  
Harris of Richmond, Baroness Content  
Hussain, Lord Content  
Hussein-Ece, Baroness Content  
Jolly, Baroness Content  
Kirkwood of Kirkhope, Lord Content  
Kramer, Baroness Content  
Lee of Trafford, Lord Content  
Ludford, Baroness Content  
Maddock, Baroness Content  
Marks of Henley-on-Thames, Lord Content  
McNally, Lord Content  
Newby, Lord Content  
Northover, Baroness Content  
Paddick, Lord Content  
Palmer of Childs Hill, Lord Content  
Purvis of Tweed, Lord Content  
Randerson, Baroness Content  
Razzall, Lord Content  
Rennard, Lord Content  
Roberts of Llandudno, Lord Content  
Sharkey, Lord Content  
Sheehan, Baroness Content  
Shipley, Lord Content  
Smith of Clifton, Lord Content  
Smith of Newnham, Baroness Content  
Steel of Aikwood, Lord Content  
Stephen, Lord Content  
Stoneham of Droxford, Lord Content  
Strasburger, Lord Content  
Stunell, Lord Content  
Suttie, Baroness Content  
Taverne, Lord Content  
Taylor of Goss Moor, Lord Content  
Teverson, Lord Content  
Thomas of Gresford, Lord Content  
Thomas of Winchester, Baroness Content  
Thornhill, Baroness Content  
Thurso, Viscount Content  
Tope, Lord Content  
Tyler of Enfield, Baroness Content  
Tyler, Lord Content  
Wallace of Saltaire, Lord Content  
Wallace of Tankerness, Lord Content  
Walmsley, Baroness Content  
Watson of Richmond, Lord Content  
Willis of Knaresborough, Lord Content  
Wrigglesworth, Lord Content  
Other 11
Ahmed, Lord Content  
Bhatia, Lord Content  
Eatwell, Lord Content  
Mackenzie of Framwellgate, Lord Content  
Mitchell, Lord Content  
Paul, Lord Content  
Rogan, Lord Content  
Stoddart of Swindon, Lord Content  
Tonge, Baroness Content  
Truscott, Lord Content  
Uddin, Baroness Content  
Not Contents Total: 201
Conservative 182
Agnew of Oulton, Lord Not Content  
Anelay of St Johns, Baroness Not Content  
Arbuthnot of Edrom, Lord Not Content  
Ashton of Hyde, Lord Not Content  
Astor of Hever, Lord Not Content  
Attlee, Earl Not Content  
Balfe, Lord Not Content  
Barker of Battle, Lord Not Content  
Bates, Lord Not Content  
Bell, Lord Not Content  
Berridge, Baroness Not Content  
Bertin, Baroness Not Content  
Blackwell, Lord Not Content  
Blencathra, Lord Not Content  
Bloomfield of Hinton Waldrist, Baroness Not Content  
Borwick, Lord Not Content  
Bourne of Aberystwyth, Lord Not Content  
Bowness, Lord Not Content  
Brabazon of Tara, Lord Not Content  
Brady, Baroness Not Content  
Bridgeman, Viscount Not Content  
Brougham and Vaux, Lord Not Content  
Buscombe, Baroness Not Content  
Byford, Baroness Not Content  
Caine, Lord Not Content  
Caithness, Earl Not Content  
Callanan, Lord Not Content  
Carrington of Fulham, Lord Not Content  
Cathcart, Earl Not Content  
Cavendish of Furness, Lord Not Content  
Chadlington, Lord Not Content  
Chalker of Wallasey, Baroness Not Content  
Chisholm of Owlpen, Baroness Not Content  
Colgrain, Lord Not Content  
Colwyn, Lord Not Content  
Cooper of Windrush, Lord Not Content  
Cope of Berkeley, Lord Not Content  
Cormack, Lord Not Content  
Courtown, Earl Not Content  
Couttie, Baroness Not Content  
Crathorne, Lord Not Content  
Dixon-Smith, Lord Not Content  
Duncan of Springbank, Lord Not Content  
Dundee, Earl Not Content  
Dunlop, Lord Not Content  
Eaton, Baroness Not Content  
Eccles, Viscount Not Content  
Elton, Lord Not Content  
Evans of Bowes Park, Baroness Not Content  
Fairfax of Cameron, Lord Not Content  
Fairhead, Baroness Not Content  
Fall, Baroness Not Content  
Farmer, Lord Not Content  
Faulks, Lord Not Content  
Fellowes of West Stafford, Lord Not Content  
Finn, Baroness Not Content  
Forsyth of Drumlean, Lord Not Content  
Framlingham, Lord Not Content  
Fraser of Corriegarth, Lord Not Content  
Freeman, Lord Not Content  
Freud, Lord Not Content  
Gardiner of Kimble, Lord Not Content  
Gardner of Parkes, Baroness Not Content  
Garel-Jones, Lord Not Content  
Geddes, Lord Not Content  
Gilbert of Panteg, Lord Not Content  
Glenarthur, Lord Not Content  
Goldie, Baroness Not Content  
Goodlad, Lord Not Content  
Grade of Yarmouth, Lord Not Content  
Griffiths of Fforestfach, Lord Not Content  
Hague of Richmond, Lord Not Content  
Hamilton of Epsom, Lord Not Content  
Hanham, Baroness Not Content  
Harding of Winscombe, Baroness Not Content  
Harris of Peckham, Lord Not Content  
Hayward, Lord Not Content  
Helic, Baroness Not Content  
Henley, Lord Not Content  
Higgins, Lord Not Content  
Hill of Oareford, Lord Not Content  
Hodgson of Abinger, Baroness Not Content  
Holmes of Richmond, Lord Not Content  
Home, Earl Not Content  
Hooper, Baroness Not Content  
Horam, Lord Not Content  
Howard of Lympne, Lord Not Content  
Howard of Rising, Lord Not Content  
Howe, Earl Not Content  
Hunt of Wirral, Lord Not Content  
Inglewood, Lord Not Content  
James of Blackheath, Lord Not Content  
Jenkin of Kennington, Baroness Not Content  
Jopling, Lord Not Content  
Keen of Elie, Lord Not Content  
King of Bridgwater, Lord Not Content  
Kirkhope of Harrogate, Lord Not Content  
Lamont of Lerwick, Lord Not Content  
Lang of Monkton, Lord Not Content  
Lansley, Lord Not Content  
Lawson of Blaby, Lord Not Content  
Leigh of Hurley, Lord Not Content  
Lexden, Lord Not Content  
Lindsay, Earl Not Content  
Lingfield, Lord Not Content  
Liverpool, Earl Not Content  
Lothian, Marquess Not Content  
MacGregor of Pulham Market, Lord Not Content  
Mancroft, Lord Not Content  
Manzoor, Baroness Not Content  
Marlesford, Lord Not Content  
McColl of Dulwich, Lord Not Content  
McInnes of Kilwinning, Lord Not Content  
McIntosh of Pickering, Baroness Not Content  
Montrose, Duke Not Content  
Morris of Bolton, Baroness Not Content  
Moynihan, Lord Not Content  
Naseby, Lord Not Content  
Nash, Lord Not Content  
Neville-Jones, Baroness Not Content  
Neville-Rolfe, Baroness Not Content  
Newlove, Baroness Not Content  
Noakes, Baroness Not Content  
Norton of Louth, Lord Not Content  
O'Cathain, Baroness Not Content  
Oppenheim-Barnes, Baroness Not Content  
O'Shaughnessy, Lord Not Content  
Palumbo, Lord Not Content  
Patten, Lord Not Content  
Pidding, Baroness Not Content  
Popat, Lord Not Content  
Porter of Spalding, Lord Not Content  
Price, Lord Not Content  
Prior of Brampton, Lord Not Content  
Rawlings, Baroness Not Content  
Redfern, Baroness Not Content  
Ridley, Viscount Not Content  
Risby, Lord Not Content  
Robathan, Lord Not Content  
Rock, Baroness Not Content  
Rotherwick, Lord Not Content  
Ryder of Wensum, Lord Not Content  
Sanderson of Bowden, Lord Not Content  
Sassoon, Lord Not Content  
Seccombe, Baroness Not Content  
Selborne, Earl Not Content  
Selkirk of Douglas, Lord Not Content  
Selsdon, Lord Not Content  
Sharples, Baroness Not Content  
Sheikh, Lord Not Content  
Sherbourne of Didsbury, Lord Not Content  
Shields, Baroness Not Content  
Shinkwin, Lord Not Content  
Skelmersdale, Lord Not Content  
Smith of Hindhead, Lord Not Content  
Spicer, Lord Not Content  
Stedman-Scott, Baroness Not Content  
Sterling of Plaistow, Lord Not Content  
Stowell of Beeston, Baroness Not Content  
Strathclyde, Lord Not Content  
Stroud, Baroness Not Content  
Sugg, Baroness Not Content  
Suri, Lord Not Content  
Swinfen, Lord Not Content  
Taylor of Holbeach, Lord Not Content  
Trimble, Lord Not Content  
True, Lord Not Content  
Tugendhat, Lord Not Content  
Ullswater, Viscount Not Content  
Vere of Norbiton, Baroness Not Content  
Verma, Baroness Not Content  
Vinson, Lord Not Content  
Wakeham, Lord Not Content  
Warsi, Baroness Not Content  
Wasserman, Lord Not Content  
Wei, Lord Not Content  
Wellington, Duke Not Content  
Whitby, Lord Not Content  
Wilcox, Baroness Not Content  
Williams of Trafford, Baroness Not Content  
Young of Cookham, Lord Not Content  
Younger of Leckie, Viscount Not Content  
Crossbench 13
Armstrong of Ilminster, Lord Not Content  
Colville of Culross, Viscount Not Content  
Dykes, Lord Not Content  
Fellowes, Lord Not Content  
Greenway, Lord Not Content  
Janvrin, Lord Not Content  
Kakkar, Lord Not Content  
Kilclooney, Lord Not Content  
Macpherson of Earl's Court, Lord Not Content  
Ramsbotham, Lord Not Content  
Somerset, Duke Not Content  
St John of Bletso, Lord Not Content  
Waverley, Viscount Not Content  
Other 6
Browne of Belmont, Lord Not Content  
Empey, Lord Not Content  
Hay of Ballyore, Lord Not Content  
Kalms, Lord Not Content  
Morrow, Lord Not Content  
Taylor of Warwick, Lord Not Content