23 July 2009
SCIENCE REDUCED TO POLITICAL BARGAINING CHIP: MPS SAY GOVERNMENT MUST RAISE ITS GAME
The Government has reduced science to a political bargaining chip and must raise its game to produce an ambitious science and engineering strategy for the future, conclude MPs in a report published today.
The Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Committee says that while there are many positives to take from its inquiry into science and engineering policy in Government, such as the growth of the science and engineering community in the civil service, a broad vision is missing.
The failure to find a stable home for the Government Office for Science has reduced science and engineering advice to, at best, a peripheral policy concern, and, at worst, a political bargaining chip. The Committee directly appeals to the Prime Minister to bring GO-Science into the Cabinet Office and it urges the creation of a Government Chief Engineer and a Government Chief Scientist.
To improve transparency and safeguard the independence of scientific advice, the Government should establish a press office in GO-Science which would also serve all the Science Advisory Committees.
The independence of scientific advisers is crucial. The criticism by the Home Secretary of Professor David Nutt, Chairman of the Advisory Council for the Misuse of Drugs, after his comments about ecstasy could deter experts from serving on Scientific Advisory Committees. It is vital that in such cases the Government Chief Scientific Adviser steps up and offers public support to safeguard the independence the advisory system.
The report also says:
If the Government is to return to 'picking winners' it must have clear priorities and come clean about which areas of research will get less money
The 2009 Budget Research Council savings are in reality an attempt to influence research funding streams and the Government should not label them as something they are not
The Haldane Principle should be replaced with a principle which accommodates a much wider range of factors, for example regional science policy
After the general election, a new free-standing Science, Engineering and Technology Committee should be created with a cross-departmental remit
Phil Willis MP, the Chairman of the Committee, said:
"My Committee does not underestimate how important the Government believes the role of science and engineering advice to be. We were impressed by evidence demonstrating that significant progress is being made, such as the increasing use of Chief Scientific Advisers.
"We ask that a tangible and ambitious strategy for UK science and engineering policy is developed. The Government has committed to placing science and engineering advice at the heart of policy formulation and now it is time to do so: scrutiny of policy must be strengthened and a clearer vision for the future must be developed."
NOTES TO EDITORS:
For media inquiries please call Becky Jones on 020 7219 5693. For any other information please call Andrew Boyd, on 020 7219 2793.
The Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Committee will publish its Eighth Report of Session 2008-09, Putting Science and Engineering at the Heart of Government Policy, (HC 168) at 00.01 am on Thursday 23 July 2009. Volume II, containing the oral and written evidence is also published on Thursday 23 July. Contributors to the Committee's inquiry will receive a hard copy of the Report and may request a hard copy of Volume II from the Committee Office; the evidence will be placed on the Committee's website on publication. Copies of the report and evidence can be obtained from TSO outlets and from the Parliamentary Bookshop, 12 Bridge Street, Parliament Square, London SW1A 2JX (020 7219 3890) upon publication by quoting the appropriate HC number