In a report released today, the Public Administration Select Committee (PASC) has found that there is a "fundamental difference of view" between the Government and others over whether there is a continuing need for the functions performed by the Administrative Justice and Tribunals Council (AJTC).
PASC also doubted the level of cost savings that the Government estimates will be achieved by the abolition of the AJTC, and called for Ministers to provide further details to support its estimate.
"Administrative justice" includes the procedures used by public authorities for making decisions in relation to individual people, the law that regulates decision-making, and the systems (such as some tribunals and ombudsmen) that enable people to challenge these decisions. There are around 650,000 administrative justice hearings each year - more than three times the number of criminal justice hearings - and it is estimated that resolving citizen’s complaints costs central government over £500 million per year.
The functions of the AJTC include keeping the whole administrative system under review and considering ways to make the system accessible, fair and efficient. The Government proposes to abolish the AJTC using powers in the Public Bodies Act 2011, and to give its functions to the Ministry of Justice. It is expected to bring forward the necessary secondary legislation later this year.
The Committee found that the Government's rationale for winding up the AJTC was questionable, and that the Ministry of Justice may not have either the resources or the expertise to take on its functions. PASC also recommended that the House of Commons Justice Committee take its findings from this inquiry into account when it considers the Government’s proposed legislation.
Bernard Jenkin MP, Chair of the Committee said:
"The AJTC should be part of the machinery to help government get decisions 'right first time'. Instead, over half a million decisions have to be reviewed each year, at great cost and considerable injustice and inconvenience to citizens. If the AJTC is abolished, what will take its place, and how will Government do better?"