Tackling inequalities in life expectancy in areas with the worst health and deprivation

02 November 2010

Third Report of Session 2010-11

The Rt Hon Margaret Hodge MP, Chair of the Committee of Public Accounts, today said:

“A central challenge for all governments is to reduce health inequalities between the affluent and the disadvantaged. The problem is complex but the fact that the gap continues to widen is of great concern, especially against a background of a general improvement in public health over the last decade.

The Department of Health has been exceptionally slow to tackle this problem. The Department knew in 1997, for instance, that certain low cost treatments, such as those to help smokers quit and those to prevent heart attacks, could have a major effect in deprived areas, but such treatments have still not been adopted on the scale required.”

Margaret Hodge was speaking as the Committee published its 3rd Report of this Session which, on the basis of evidence from the Department of Health (the Department), examined why it had failed to meet its health inequalities target, the role of GPs, and the lessons of this for the new NHS

Inequalities in health outcomes between the most affluent and disadvantaged members of society are longstanding, deep-seated and have proved difficult to change. In 1997, the Government put tackling health inequalities at the heart of its health agenda and subsequently published a number of policy documents and related targets. In 2004 the Government set the Department the target of reducing the gap in life expectancy between 70 ‘spearhead’ local authorities with high deprivation and the population as a whole by 10 per cent by 2010. The Department has not met this target and has been exceptionally slow to tackle health inequalities. 

Whilst it is heartening to recognise the overall improvements in health over the last decade it is of great concern that inequality in health has increased. The Department should be commended for setting out to tackle a problem that has proved historically to be so intractable. However, we find it unacceptable that it took it until 2006 - nine years after it announced the importance of tackling health inequalities - to establish this as an NHS priority. Although it was known in 1997 that certain key interventions such as smoking cessation had the most impact on the health of those living in deprived areas, it took the Department until 2007 to produce evidence about how such treatments could be delivered cost-effectively.

GPs are crucial to improving the health of people in the most deprived areas.  However, in many of these areas the number of GPs per head of population is well below the number in more affluent areas. The Department missed an opportunity to use the revised GP contract to ensure more doctors work in deprived areas, and has not focused their attention sufficiently on implementing the key interventions that would make a difference.

“Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS” sets out the Government’s long-term vision for the NHS. In the transitional period while this change is managed, it is important that tackling health inequalities does not slip down the Department’s agenda. The Department will need to set a clear framework of accountability at all levels of the health service if it is to be successful in addressing health inequalities in future.

All media enquiries to:
Alex Paterson
Select Committee Media Officer
Tel: 020 7219 1589
Mobile: 07917 488488

Share this page