COMMONS

Smart Meter roll-out

Submit evidence online

Written evidence to the inquiry can be submitted online:

20 December 2012

Smart meters and smart grids have the potential to bring many benefits to the energy industry and to consumers.

For example, energy suppliers are expected to benefit from reduced operating and generation costs, and some of these savings should be passed on to consumers through lower energy prices. Consumers are also expected to benefit from using the information about energy use provided by the in-home display to reduce their energy consumption and save money on their energy bills. In future, automated controls and smart appliances may help consumers to reduce their energy use further.

Some consumers have smart meters already, but most people will not get them until the mass roll-out programme between 2014 and 2019. Evidence from our recent Consumer Engagement inquiry suggests that currently about half of people have heard of smart meters and that not all of them support roll-out. If engagement levels do not increase and people refuse to allow smart meters to be installed in their home, then roll-out may be hindered and consumers may not benefit from the technology as they could. Consumer concerns have hampered roll-out in other countries, and in this inquiry we seek to learn how such concerns could be addressed in order to prevent similar problems in the UK.

The Government has conducted several consultations on different aspects of its Smart Metering Implementation Programme this year and has recently published its responses to these consultations. In its response to the consultation on the Consumer Engagement Strategy, it stated that the larger suppliers will now be required to set up a Central Delivery Body to undertake a centralised engagement programme. 

Terms of reference

The Committee will monitor progress towards delivering the smart meter roll-out. We now invite written evidence on any or all of the following terms of reference:

  •  Are the Government’s cost and timescale predictions for roll-out realistic and will it deliver value for money?
  • What are the potential benefits of smart meters for consumers, and what barriers need to be overcome in order for consumers to realise them?
  • Is there a possibility that suppliers will gain considerably more than consumers from smart meters? Is enough being done to ensure that any financial benefits accruing to suppliers will be passed on to consumers?
  • What lessons can be learned from successful smart meter implementation and usage elsewhere in the world?
  • Will smart meters empower customers to take greater control of their energy consumption?
  • Will consumers on pre-pay meters obtain the same benefits from smart meters as other consumers?
  • Should vulnerable customers and the fuel-poor be first in line for smart meters so they can get the benefits sooner?
  • What is the best way of involving third-party trusted messengers, such as charities, consumer groups, community organisations, local authorities and housing associations in roll-out?
  • What are the potential obstacles to rolling out smart meters in the UK and how should these be addressed? What pitfalls have hindered roll-out programmes elsewhere and are we doing all we can to avoid them?
  • Are levels of public awareness of and support for smart meter roll-out increasing?
  • Is enough being done to increase consumer awareness about smart meters?  Could DECC’s consumer engagement strategy be improved?
  • Are consumers’ concerns about privacy and health being addressed adequately?
  • Is there any evidence that consumers’ concerns about smart meters are declining or growing?
  • Will the commercial benefits of smart meter roll-out be captured within the UK?
  • Will DECC’s current approach to roll-out, including on procurement and establishment of the central Data and Communications Company, deliver an optimal data and communications strategy?
  • What criteria should DECC use to measure the ongoing success of roll-out?               

The deadline for the submission of written evidence is 07 February 2013

Notes on submission of written evidence

As part of a scheme to encourage paperless working and maximise efficiency, the Committee is piloting a new web portal for online submission of written evidence. Written submissions for this inquiry should therefore be sent via the link at the top of this page.

The deadline is Thursday 07 February 2013. As a guideline submissions should be no longer than 3000 words, please contact the Committee staff if you wish to discuss this. If you need to send hard copy please send it to: The Clerk, Energy and Climate Change Committee, 7 Millbank, London, SW1P 3JA.

 Submissions should be a Word document, in the format of a self-contained memorandum. Paragraphs should be numbered for ease of reference, and the document should, if possible, include an executive summary.

Submissions should be original work, not previously published or circulated elsewhere. Once submitted, your submission becomes the property of the Committee and no public use should be made of it unless you have first obtained permission from the Clerk of the Committee. Please bear in mind that Committees are not able to investigate individual cases.

The Committee normally, though not always, chooses to publish the written evidence it receives, either by printing the evidence, publishing it on the internet or by making it publicly available through the Parliamentary Archives. If there is any information you believe to be sensitive you should highlight it and explain what harm you believe would result from its disclosure; the Committee will take this into account in deciding whether to publish or further disclose the evidence.

You should be aware that there may be circumstances in which the House of Commons will be required to communicate information to third parties on request, in order to comply with its obligations under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

Image: iStockphoto

Written evidence

Submitted by Date published
John Cowburn  John Cowburn (PDF) 04 March 2013
Alex Henney  Alex Henney (PDF) 04 March 2013
John Cowburn  John Cowburn (PDF) 04 March 2013
National Grid Metering  National Grid Metering (PDF) 04 March 2013
Paul Lewis  Paul Lewis (PDF) 04 March 2013
Allison Rice  Allison Rice (PDF) 04 March 2013
Olle Johansson  Olle Johansson (PDF) 04 March 2013
DR ROBERT ZAC COX BDS  DR ROBERT ZAC COX BDS (PDF) 04 March 2013
Elizabeth Evans  Elizabeth Evans (PDF) 04 March 2013
Bio-Electromagnetic Research Initiative (www.bemri.org)  Bio-Electromagnetic Research Initiative (www.bemri.org) (PDF) 04 March 2013
Richard Phillips  Richard Phillips (PDF) 04 March 2013
A S Fitzgerald  A S Fitzgerald (PDF) 04 March 2013
World Foundation for Natural Science  World Foundation for Natural Science (PDF) 04 March 2013
John Cox  John Cox (PDF) 04 March 2013
julia Taylor  julia Taylor (PDF) 04 March 2013
E.ON  E.ON (PDF) 04 March 2013
Sarah Wright  Sarah Wright (PDF) 04 March 2013
Telefónica  Telefónica (PDF) 04 March 2013
The Healthy House Ltd  The Healthy House Ltd (PDF) 04 March 2013
Glynis Evans  Glynis Evans (PDF) 04 March 2013
Ashleigh Marsh  Ashleigh Marsh (PDF) 04 March 2013
Karl Cox  Karl Cox (PDF) 04 March 2013
J Sapphire  J Sapphire (PDF) 04 March 2013
Yvonne Tinckler  Yvonne Tinckler (PDF) 04 March 2013
Marion Welton  Marion Welton (PDF) 04 March 2013
Dr Andrew Tresidder MRCGP  Dr Andrew Tresidder MRCGP (PDF) 04 March 2013
Carol Bloxsome  Carol Bloxsome (PDF) 04 March 2013
Powerwatch  Powerwatch (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mrs Nash  Mrs Nash (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mrs Thompson  Mrs Thompson (PDF) 04 March 2013
Gail Holmewood  Gail Holmewood (PDF) 04 March 2013
Anne Gill  Anne Gill (PDF) 04 March 2013
Stop Smart Meters (UK)  Stop Smart Meters (UK) (PDF) 04 March 2013
Charles  Charles (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mast Sanity  Mast Sanity (PDF) 04 March 2013
ElectroSensitivity UK  ElectroSensitivity UK (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mrs Margaret White  Mrs Margaret White (PDF) 04 March 2013
Charlotte Bradstock  Charlotte Bradstock (PDF) 04 March 2013
All-Party Parliamentary Carbon Monoxide Group  All-Party Parliamentary Carbon Monoxide Group (PDF) 04 March 2013
Don Skelton  Don Skelton (PDF) 04 March 2013
Dr Andrew Goldsworthy  Dr Andrew Goldsworthy (PDF) 04 March 2013
Abigail Hirschmann  Abigail Hirschmann (PDF) 04 March 2013
Caroline Davies  Caroline Davies (PDF) 04 March 2013
BioSustainable Design  BioSustainable Design (PDF) 04 March 2013
Rose Hunt  Rose Hunt (PDF) 04 March 2013
keith dixon  keith dixon (PDF) 04 March 2013
Itron  Itron (PDF) 04 March 2013
Marion Eaton  Marion Eaton (PDF) 04 March 2013
Barbara Norden  Barbara Norden (PDF) 04 March 2013
jody law  jody law (PDF) 04 March 2013
Miss Velma Lyrae  Miss Velma Lyrae (PDF) 04 March 2013
Susan Ledger  Susan Ledger (PDF) 04 March 2013
Lloyd Burrell  Lloyd Burrell (PDF) 04 March 2013
Eleanor Chandler  Eleanor Chandler (PDF) 04 March 2013
Paula Robinson  Paula Robinson (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mrs M Brown  Mrs M Brown (PDF) 04 March 2013
Ann Wade  Ann Wade (PDF) 04 March 2013
Charles Simpson  Charles Simpson (PDF) 04 March 2013
SSITA and CAVI Society - on behalf of both.  SSITA and CAVI Society - on behalf of both. (PDF) 04 March 2013
Helen Lovell  Helen Lovell (PDF) 04 March 2013
MCS-Aware  MCS-Aware (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mary Hood  Mary Hood (PDF) 04 March 2013
The Institution of Engineering and Technology  The Institution of Engineering and Technology (PDF) 04 March 2013
Ofgem  Ofgem (PDF) 04 March 2013
Peter Kalinowski  Peter Kalinowski (PDF) 04 March 2013
MRS KRYSTYNA BROWN  MRS KRYSTYNA BROWN (PDF) 04 March 2013
Jeff Jeffries  Jeff Jeffries (PDF) 04 March 2013
Anthony Morris  Anthony Morris (PDF) 04 March 2013
Robert Pursall  Robert Pursall (PDF) 04 March 2013
RWE npower  RWE npower (PDF) 04 March 2013
john muir  john muir (PDF) 04 March 2013
First Utility  First Utility (PDF) 04 March 2013
Susan Nicholls  Susan Nicholls (PDF) 04 March 2013
SSE  SSE (PDF) 04 March 2013
John Weigel  John Weigel (PDF) 04 March 2013
Monika Curry  Monika Curry (PDF) 04 March 2013
Alliance for Natural Health International  Alliance for Natural Health International (PDF) 04 March 2013
ElectraLink Ltd  ElectraLink Ltd (PDF) 04 March 2013
Louise Larchbourne  Louise Larchbourne (PDF) 04 March 2013
Miss J Ware  Miss J Ware (PDF) 04 March 2013
Therese Howell  Therese Howell (PDF) 04 March 2013
Alix Longman  Alix Longman (PDF) 04 March 2013
David Scranage  David Scranage (PDF) 04 March 2013
Anna Peckham  Anna Peckham (PDF) 04 March 2013
M Beresford  M Beresford (PDF) 04 March 2013
Amanda Blay  Amanda Blay (PDF) 04 March 2013
Orsis (UK) Ltd  Orsis (UK) Ltd (PDF) 04 March 2013
Katie Saunders  Katie Saunders (PDF) 04 March 2013
Caroline Spear  Caroline Spear (PDF) 04 March 2013
Jackie Leach  Jackie Leach (PDF) 04 March 2013
FoodsMatter  FoodsMatter (PDF) 04 March 2013
Lynn Alford-Burow  Lynn Alford-Burow (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mark Watson  Mark Watson (PDF) 04 March 2013
Gurmit Singh  Gurmit Singh (PDF) 04 March 2013
Sophie Austin  Sophie Austin (PDF) 04 March 2013
DECC  DECC (PDF) 04 March 2013
Damian May  Damian May (PDF) 04 March 2013
Helen Malik  Helen Malik (PDF) 04 March 2013
EDF Energy  EDF Energy (PDF) 04 March 2013
Energy UK  Energy UK (PDF) 04 March 2013
Leigh William Gregson  Leigh William Gregson (PDF) 04 March 2013
SmartReach  SmartReach (PDF) 04 March 2013
BEAMA  BEAMA (PDF) 04 March 2013
Mrs Claire Smith  Mrs Claire Smith (PDF) 04 March 2013
British Gas  British Gas (PDF) 04 March 2013
Catarina Geoghan  Catarina Geoghan (PDF) 04 March 2013
ScottishPower  ScottishPower (PDF) 04 March 2013
Consumer Focus  Consumer Focus (PDF) 04 March 2013
Rachel Acworth  Rachel Acworth (PDF) 04 March 2013
Federation of Small Businesses  Federation of Small Businesses (PDF) 04 March 2013
Policy Exchange  Policy Exchange (PDF) 04 March 2013
Ann Gore  Ann Gore (PDF) 04 March 2013
The Health Protection Agency  The Health Protection Agency (PDF) 04 March 2013
ESTA  ESTA (PDF) 04 March 2013